username:
password:
register
(it's free!)
home
social
community
all member circles
member blogs
member photo albums
circles main page
personal mail
submit an event
mailing lists
follow us on twitter
follow us on facebook
patterns
create a pattern
my downloads (0 items)
premier features
Pdf Private Label Entry
subscribe
feature comparison
premier support area
sell a pattern
upload a free pattern
my uploaded patterns
pattern wizard support
free pattern wizard features
free pattern downloads
learn
multimedia
fun
links
member showcase
beadcast.com
fun stitching videos
greeting cards
stitch goddess blog
contests
shop
Stitchboard Mall
gift registry
vendor registration
my area
my stash
view my profile
privacy settings
change profile settings
change active avatar picture
change my preferences
vendor registration
commercial member
other
credits
welcome
faqs
donate
terms of service
privacy policy
membership agreement
contact us
community home
>
Crochet
>
Crochet Hints and Tips
> Yarn standards
Yarn standards
3528 views 4 replies
Latest reply: July 18, 2013 at 9:36:56 PM
Member since:
Jul 3, 2013
Posts: 575
BetwixtTheStitch
message #1
Yarn standards
July 17, 2013 at 8:44:22 AM
I was trying to post a link to the Craft Yarn Council standards page, however firefox won't allow it
.
I'd like to see a discussion about yarn in general and thought the labeling standards would be a good place to start.
Of course the standards are interpreted loosely by manufacturers, so a place to talk about it and post what we have learned from experience seems very appropriate.
Sherry
Look at that smile! (Photo guaranteed unretouched)
Member since:
Jul 1, 2009
Posts: 4610
Stitchboard Admin
message #2
Re: Yarn standards
July 17, 2013 at 3:24:27 PM (in response to BetwixtTheStitch message #1)
Thank you for starting this discussion!
It's one I've wanted to have for a long time.
Here's the link to the CYC standards page:
http://www.craftyarncouncil.com/weight.html
My take on it is this: these are supposed to be standards, but sadly, I find they're all over the place. I wrote about it some time ago in my (sorely neglected) blog:
/stitchgoddess/?p=17
Until manufacturers and publishers are held to
exactly
the same standards, it's going to be dicey. Some manufacturers still don't use these numbers, either!
I don't mind looking at a yarn label and seeing a gauge, rather than the craft yarn council "standards," but I mind when the gauge is, say, knitted with a lightweight yarn on ridiculously large needles, because then I can't really tell a single thing about the yarn.
As long as a yarn can be given any one of a number of designations, the system is pretty unhelpful to me. While it works fine for a known knitting worsted or a known sport weight, it doesn't really work when a sport and a baby yarn can be similarly classified with a #2 rating, though the baby weight may be far thinner. Yet with the "old" way of doing things, I would know that if I was looking for a thinner yarn, I'd look for baby weight, and a sport weight would do if I wanted something a bit thicker, yet not as thick as a worsted.
LOL, you can probably tell I've known this kind of frustration from painful experience!
How have your experiences been with the "new" standards?
Melanie (cat slave and Official Feline Can Opener) =^.^=
~~~~~
I'm a beading, knitting and crochet addict. If that means I'm admitting I have a problem, then I admit to nothing. Please refrain from helping me.
Member since:
Jul 3, 2013
Posts: 575
BetwixtTheStitch
message #3
Re: Yarn standards
July 18, 2013 at 8:18:23 AM (in response to BetwixtTheStitch message #1)
This is exactly why I wanted to have this discussion! I have known this frustration as well and I would like to make sure that newbies understand that it may not be them, maybe it's the yarn or the "designations".
The gauge should be taken with a grain of salt, I do a test swatch and count the stitches myself when gauge is important.
Sherry
Member since:
Jul 3, 2013
Posts: 575
BetwixtTheStitch
message #4
Re: Yarn standards
July 18, 2013 at 8:33:57 AM (in response to BetwixtTheStitch message #1)
I've thought about blogging as well
, however my back won't allow me to sit at the computer for the amount of time required so a forum such as this is a perfect place for me to contribute a little and learn some too.
Sherry
Look at that smile! (Photo guaranteed unretouched)
Member since:
Jul 1, 2009
Posts: 4610
Stitchboard Admin
message #5
Re: Yarn standards
July 18, 2013 at 9:36:56 PM (in response to BetwixtTheStitch message #3)
I'm so glad you've wanted to have this discussion, too!
Gauge is
such
an important issue!
I definitely agree...anyone who is new to crochet or knitting needs to know there can be a
huge
difference between a "standard" and what works for
them
. Everything must be swatched first.
IMO, it's a big disappointment that the standards aren't purely across the board. Or that going with the new standards has replaced the old standards in some cases. If the new standards worked, it would be a different story, but they're too nebulous and open to interpretation.
Like honesty, swatching and blocking are always the best policy. I hate swatching for so many reasons...it's time consuming and (unlike what I was incorrectly told years ago) you really can't simply undo the swatch after you've blocked it and reuse the yarn. OTOH, what's a little swatching compared to finding a garment is much too big or much too small? Starting something over from scratch (unless you're talking about small doll clothes) is even more time consuming than swatching. I'd much rather make a sweater once than make it twice.
As for blogs, I'm afraid I'm quite long-winded.
Feel free to use our blogs here to write a simple sentence or two about what you're doing, should the mood strike. The software should be improving, but for now, if you'd merely like to discuss your project du jour or thoughts on whatever, we'd love to hear, even if it's only a couple of lines!
Melanie (cat slave and Official Feline Can Opener) =^.^=
~~~~~
I'm a beading, knitting and crochet addict. If that means I'm admitting I have a problem, then I admit to nothing. Please refrain from helping me.
freePatternWizard
Premier Features
300 Stitches Across
500 Stitches Across
Filet Crochet
NEW!
Illusion Knitting
Private Label Pdfs
FAQs
•
Terms of Service
•
Info on Selling Your Own Patterns
•
Privacy Policy
•
Contact Us
© copyright 2010-2024 Stitchboard.com All rights reserved